So it’s “Song From The Year You Were Born” night, and I suddenly get sad for all those kids just coming up who one day with only have Katy Perry songs to choose from.

He went last, but since Adam Lambert again grabbed this thing and ran with it, I’ll start with him. Of course he did “Mad World” by Tears For Fears, because that’s what melodramatic baby goths do. And it’s gorgeous. This is what he should be concentrating on – songs that show off his voice but don’t have him running around like a big cartoon. He’s a smart, talented boy, and if he keeps this up, he’s almost golden. I love Kris Allen more. But the people seem to be on the Adam train.
– Our first singer is Danny Gokey, who was born in 1980. We almost have the same birthday, several years apart. He’s the oldest of the Idols, which means I could have babysat all of them – I love being old.
He’s doing Mickey Gilley’s version of Stand By Me. Why? And the kids are “Mickey Mouse’s last name is Gilley?”
It’s not bad! The arrangement was a little precious, like “Watch me be artsy!” But he’s got a great voice and I’m not bored this week, so good on ya. But I wish he’d done something better, like The Commodore’s “Still.” He does love the sad songs.
– Kris Allen: The Cougar’s Choice!:He was born June 21, 1985. As a kid he wanted to drive a taxi, like Harry Chapin. (Ask your parents). So of all the songs from 1985, he picks “All She Wants To Do Is Dance?” What is this awful arrangement? Why does it sound like Stevie Wonder arranged this on his way back from the “Part Time Lover” sessions? And then told that joke about driving home, and everybody had to laugh because it’s Stevie Wonder, even though he technically can’t see you if you don’t?
Kara said it sounded like music theory class homework, Simon said it was forgettable, Randy made sure everybody knew that he knows who produced the Don Henley version, and Paula talked about his aura and magical illusions and why fools fall in love and then want to throw things at Ryan Seacrest.
– Lil was born in 1984, and she and her mom want y’all to know that her name is Lil, after her grandmother Lily, and not Lil’, after Kim. Get it right, Simon. She is Tina Turner-ing it up with “What’s Love Got To Do With It” and it’s more karaoke than you would ever believe. I am so ready for her to go home. The sad part is that she didn’t sound all that bad. But it’s a struggle and she needs to go. Simon tells her “it’s literally like we have lost you.”
Amen.
— Anoop, circa 1986, bobbles the words to “True Colors” (The darkness down inside does not make you feel strong. It makes you feels small. If darkness made you strong you would be evil. Or C. Thomas Howell from “Red Dawn” (Ask your folks, kids!) But he sounds great I love him. Can’t help it.
— Oh, Scott, our Basket of Puppies from 1985. He’s singing Survivor’s “The Search Is Over,” to “get in touch with his punk side.” There is so much wrong with that statement that I can’t even begin. Yes I can. It’s a power ballad, man! It’s the opposite of punk! His voice is just OK. If he was gonna go cheese he should have done John Parr’s “St. Elmo’s Fire (Man In Motion).” I like that he’s trying to be fun. But he can go home. Before Lil.
— Allison was born in 1992, around my 21st birthday. I remember spending it walking around college wondering if I’d bought the right gross fruit drink for my introduction in legal drinky-poo. She sounds great on “I Can’t Make You Love Me” but I can’t help but be sad that she’s singing about sleeping with a guy who doesn’t love her as much as she loves him, so they can say goodbye and she can go crawl somewhere and weep.
— Matt Giraud, of 1985, singing the skanky “Part Time Lover.” He’s brilliant, sexy, jaunty and tuneful. The cougars have another choice.
This was so much better than it could have been! What do you think? And if you had been on the show, what song from your birth year would you have sung? I would’ve done 1971′s “Rainy Days and Mondays” because they do always get me down. Like Scott singing Survivor songs.













