Is it just me, or does this thing seem to be going on FOREVER this season?
Seacrest says that we’re just two weeks away from the finale, which means that the four kids left all have an equal shot at decent careers, if not an equal shot at winning “American Idol.” It also means that we all get our Wednesday and Thursdays back. Well, maybe you don’t want yours back…
Wait…did Seacrest just say that Lady Gaga is helping interpret the music of Leiber and Stoller, which dates back to before most of their parents? Is Gaga gonna be dressed as a hound dog with a collar made of glitter and fireflies? What is going on here?
First, the kids are gonna sing songs that inspire them, and then do the songs of Leiber and Stoller, which are justified and ancient, just like the Vengeance of Mu-Mu. Look it up, kiddies. And tell the ghost of Tammy Wynette I said “Hey.”
James introduces “Don’t Stop Believing,” from a band that one of the judges used to be in, without the backstage chatter with Jimmy Iovine. I miss him, particularly he’s usually guaranteed to be the only professional on camera that’s gonna give any sort of critique other than “You’re so pretty!” (JLo) or “Dawg, for me, Dawg…You’re back!” (Randy) or “You’re the very definition of a loose goose avoiding the noose.” (Tyler)
James is, not surprisingly, great. He’s so confident, that one, so professional but still so far from phoning it in. He’s, for lack of a better word, exciting, even on this played-into-the-ground hit. He hits all the right highs, all the emotional tags. I still feel he’s gonna win. He certainly should.
Haley does Michael Jackson’s “Earth Song,” which I don’t know well, but which she infuses with a competent combination of growl and compassion. And Jlo “can feel her feeling” but thinks that, just like last week, she ought to start pandering to the public and sing stuff they know. I get that, but I don’t love the idea that Lopez says she should “do what everyone else is doing.” Is that really what we should be telling them? Conform for the money and the votes?
I do love Haley’s exchange with Randy, because he tries tell her that she shouldn’t strain, and that the audience might respond more to a song that is more familiar…and then…OH SNAP! Tyler tells her the other judges are full of it and not to listen to them! And the audience, who by now is on RoboBoo whenever they hear anything that seems to approach criticism and not blanket butt-kissing, is confused. So is Haley. Listen, America. If no one in their lives ever tells them they are less than perfect, or that they need to work on something, they never will. Haley’s not a fragile flower. She’s trying to enter the nastiest, most cut-throat business around, and if she can’t take criticism, she doesn’t need to be in it. Seriously. They didn’t attack her with Brillo Pads and motor oil. They told her her song could be better.
Scotty, who I will never call “The Body” because it’s sorta dumb, is doing Alan Jackson’s 911-related “Where Were You When The World Stopped Turning.” He does a pretty faithful job that’s almost too faithful. It’s almost karaoke. Sorry. Boo me. I can take it. Randy seems to be treading lightly because he just is sick of being booed. I can’t really tell if he liked it, or if he’s just sure that this was a good song for him. I have to tell you that I never liked the line that admitted not being sure about the difference between Iraq and Iran. There is a difference, you know. I stand by what I’ve been saying for weeks – Scotty is an incredibly talented kid who hasn’t yet found out who he is as a singer. Sorry. Ready for him and/or Lauren to go.
Speaking of Lauren, she’s singing Martina McBride’s “Do It Anyway.” Y’all, I admit when I’m wrong, and I may have spoken too soon. She’s pretty good this week, with notes that are meaty, not showy, an amazing amount of control and a connection to the song I don’t usually feel from her. Also, she got rid of the Barbarella weave. That’s always a plus.
Hey! Jimmy’s back with Carol Channing, who joins us after passing out on top of a pile of fake eyelashes at the MAC counter after a mimosa and cupcake binge with the cast of Cirque Du Soleil. No, wait…it’s Lady Gaga, who is, under all that flash and self-promotion, a wonderful singer. Really excited to see what she does with Scotty, because she’s all about the drama, and he’s easy like Sunday morning. Gaga also seems not to be wearing pants. Dunno why. Part of the drama.
Haley is doing “I Who Have Nothing” by Shirley Bassey, one of the most melodramatic guilt trips ever recorded. Oh, this is gonna be good. Gaga tells her to take a dramatic breath, and she does. I LOVE THIS. There is such a difference between a singer like Haley who throws everything she has into her songs, emotion, voice and all, and people who just kinda sing. The judges – and this is key – defend their harshness, such as it us, because they want her to regroup and then perform like that. Seacrest tells Randy he confuses her by ever giving criticism and then makes them hug.
Sometimes…you don’t get a hug. You don’t get a lot of marshmallow fluff to take the sting off the truth. You just get truthed.
Scotty is doing “Young Blood” by the Coasters, which Gaga thinks shows his humor. She also thinks he would connect better to the song if he imagined the microphone as his girlfriend, who has threatened to leave him if he doesn’t stick his tongue down her throat. This is a wee graphic, and Scotty’s a little freaked out (I think he’s mostly joking) and wants to kiss his cross and wait for deliverance from the scary lady, but it works. Whatever she said works! Gaga, for her part, apologizes for having underestimated his conservatism. She’s sorta in her own world, that one, but she’s sweet.
Lauren is not evil. She wants you to know that, even though she’s doing Elvis’ “Trouble” in which she claims she’s evil over and over. Gaga explains that she’s doing a character, but that she should embrace her impish side. The best part of this is not Lauren’s song, which is pretty good, but Iovine’s stone-faced assertion that Gaga is “the perfect person to discuss the world ‘Evil.’” Oh, Iovine. Bless your heart.
James is trying to do the Coasters via Paul Rodgers, and Gaga, as Jimmy says, “is not having it.” She makes him rev it back up. I wish he’d been encouraged to stay within the key. But it’s super fun and he’s got mad personality. “Love Potion Number 9″ is a goofy fun song, and he captures it perfectly. Gaga is the best mentor in a while. I wish she was available to be a judge.