The Palm Beach Post
By Barbara Marshall   |  Dining  |  October 18, 2010

Holly Reith is a caterer who started in NYC, cooking for the cast of 'SNL'. (J. Gwendolynne Berry/The Palm Beach Post)

“John Belushi loved these,” says caterer Holly Reith, offering a plate of pecan pie bars. “He had a major sweet tooth.”

In her tchotchke-filled Tequesta kitchen, Reith, a former fashion model turned caterer-to-the-stars in disco-era New York, is serving up savory stories along with her Moroccan meatballs, chicken piccata and risotto. She’s also mourning the backyard chickens Martin County just forced her to give away, while stepping over her bouncing King Charles spaniel puppy and a sleeping corgi collapsed in a heap on the kitchen floor.

How the Jupiter High School graduate ended up cooking in New York then started a catering business in Palm Beach County is a tale of good luck and good looks.

Reith was working as a Worth Avenue lunch model in 1977 when she won a modeling contest in New York, wearing a homemade dress. During the next few years, she worked for Revlon, Oleg Cassini and Diane von Furstenburg – and was photographed by a very young Patrick Demarchelier. In old photos, she has a sleek all-American look, like a black-haired Shelley Hack.

The daughter and granddaughter of talented cooks, Reith began hosting dinner parties from her apartment kitchen.

“I used to poach salmon in my dishwasher,” she said.

A friend asked her to cater one of the regular Friday lunches at Arista Records. Founder Clive Davis, who discovered the Grateful Dead, Aretha Franklin and Whitney Houston, was bowled over by Reith’s blanquette de veau and caramel flan.

“That’s when I stopped modeling and starting cooking,” said Reith, scattering lemons and parsley over the chicken piccata, another of Davis’ favorite dishes.

Shortly afterward, a friendship with Bill Murray’s four brothers led to a job catering green-room meals for the early casts of Saturday Night Live.

(J. Gwendolynne Berry/The Palm Beach Post)

“They asked for a lot of desserts,” Reith recalled.

After the shows, Reith hung out with cast members including Gilda Radner, Jane Curtin, Dan Ackroyd, Belushi and later, Eddie Murphy.

“The wrap parties went on until 6 a.m.,” said Reith.

She cooked for Candice Bergen, William Safire and even Maria Callas. She served Club Med executives exotic-theme meals tied to the company’s various resorts. By the mid-1980s, she was splitting her time between New York and Palm Beach County, when she bought a small house in Tequesta and opened a restaurant in Jupiter called The Ritz. It closed after a year, but Reith said she introduced concepts in 1985 that just recently became standard restaurant fare.

“We were so ahead of our time,” she said. “We served Itsy-Bitsy Ritz-y burgers by the six pack well before anyone had heard of sliders.”

A private chef job in Palm Beach led to a summer in Newport, where she met her husband, Jonathan Pratt, who has a landscaping company. The couple settled back in Tequesta and are raising two sons, who play football at South Fork High School in Stuart. Reith opened her business, Holly Reith Catering.

As she cracks eggs over the meatballs and puts them under her broiler to cook, Reith reluctantly parts with one of her biggest cooking secrets.

The depth of flavor in her risotto con funghi and chicken piccata is due to lemon oil, a trick she picked up in Morocco.

She makes large batches by adding lemon halves to a large glass jar of olive oil and lets it steep for weeks. The result adds a bright citrus tang to everything from fish to salad dressing.

“You can’t believe what a difference it makes,” she said.

You can reach Holly Reith Catering at (561) 746-1323.

Moroccan meatballs with cumin and fried eggs. (J. Gwendolynne Berry/The Palm Beach Post)

MOROCCAN MEATBALLS

(Serves 4 to 6)

1 pound finely ground lamb

1 tablespoon chopped onion

1 tablespoon finely chopped parsley

1 tablespoon finely chopped cilantro

2 teaspoons cumin

1⁄4 teaspoon cayenne pepper

4 tablespoons olive oil

Salt

Mix all the ingredients, except the oil, in a bowl. Take a spoonful and roll into a ball about the size of a large marble. Heat the oil and brown the meat on all sides. Drain meatballs.

For the sauce:

1 large onion, chopped

1 pound tomatoes, peeled, seeded and chopped

2 garlic cloves, peeled and chopped

1 tablespoon cumin

1 teaspoon fresh black pepper

1 teaspoon cinnamon

1⁄2 teaspoon ground ginger

1⁄4 teaspoon cayenne pepper

4 medium eggs

Add all the ingredients, except eggs, to the pan. Simmer for about 30 minutes, stirring occasionally to make a thick sauce.

Return the meatballs to the pan and simmer for about 10 minutes.

Preheat oven to 400°. In a tagine or baking dish pour the meatballs and sauce; crack the eggs over the meatballs. Cover and place in oven for 12 to 15 minutes or until the whites are done, but the yolks are still liquid. Serve immediately.

Chicken picatta with homemade lemon oil, risotto con funghi and mixed grilled vegetables. (J. Gwendolynne Berry/The Palm Beach Post)

CHICKEN PICCATA

“Here is one of Clive Davis’ (Arista Records founder) favorite recipes,” says Reith.

(Serves 4)

2 pounds of chicken breasts cut into 3 to 4-ounce pieces, pounded until flat and thin

1 egg, whisked with tablespoon water (egg wash)

Combine:

1⁄2 cup flour

1⁄2 cup Italian bread crumbs

1⁄2 cup wheat germ (to give it a nutty flavor)

3⁄4 cup lemon oil (made of fermented lemons in olive oil)*

1⁄2 cup capers

1⁄2 lemon, sliced

1⁄2 cup white wine

Salt and white pepper to taste

Coat the chicken in egg wash, then dredge in flour mixture. Heat lemon oil in pan and add capers and wine. Add chicken and cook for about 3 minutes on each side. Do not overcook.

Add the lemon slices and cook for about a minute. Use lemon and capers for garnish.

* Reith makes lemon oil by adding lemon halves to a large glass jar, then covering the lemons in olive oil. She lets the lemons steep in a dark, cool place for several weeks.

Reith's pecan pie bars were a favorite of the late actor and comedian, John Belushi. (J. Gwendolynne Berry/The Palm Beach Post)

PECAN PIE BARS

“John Belushi loved this dessert.”

For the bars:

2 cups all-purpose flour

1⁄2 cup sugar

1⁄8 teaspoon salt

3⁄4 cup butter cut up

Make the bar crust:

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Combine ingredients with pastry blender until the mixture resembles fine crumbs. Press the mixture into a 13-by-9-inch greased pan.

Bake at 350 degrees until golden brown (about 20 minutes.)

For the topping:

1 cup firmly packed brown sugar

1 cup light corn syrup

1⁄2 cup butter

4 slightly beaten eggs

2 1⁄2 cups chopped pecans

1 tablespoon vanilla

Combine first three ingredients in a quart saucepan and bring to a gentle boil as you stir. Lower the heat. Ladle a bit of the sauce into a bowl and stir 1⁄4 of beaten eggs to temper. Add this mixture to the pan and stir. Then slowly stir in the remaining eggs. Add the pecans and vanilla and stir.

Pour mixture over crust and spread to cover. Return to oven at 350 degrees for 35 minutes, or until center doesn’t move.

Cool completely and cut into bars

20 Responses to “Caterer Holly Reith has memories of ‘SNL’ stirring in her kitchen”

  1. Craig says:

    What a wonderful story thank you so much for sharing your experiences and recopies.

  2. Anan Imus says:

    She’s quoted as saying, “We were so ahead of our time,” and “We served Itsy-Bitsy Ritz-y burgers by the six pack well before anyone had heard of sliders.” Really!?!

    I guess no one ever heard of White Castle in 1985 – the original “sliders”? In fact there was a Royal Castle on the corner of 45th and Broadway in the late 60′s – early 70′s (and a Whataburger on Okeechobee Blvd. in the early 80′s) that sold “itsy bitsy burgers”.

    Her invention must have been that they were sold “by the six pack”?

    • Holly Pratt says:

      I didn’t say I invented the small burger; we got the idea from White and Royal castle. In those days nobody outside of those chains were selling little burgers! Lighten up. Enjoy!

      • Anan Imus says:

        You’re the one who needs to lighten up. BTW name dropping is really pathetic – Enjoy!

      • Anna says:

        @Holly Pratt: The above-comment didn’t imply that you said you invented the small burger. However, you were quoted in the article and it clearly gives that impression, “…well before anyone had heard of sliders.” If you “got the idea from White and Royal castle”, then you should have said that and given them the credit instead of trying to take it for yourself in a self-aggrandizing manner. Your reply above now states “…nobody outside those chains were “selling” little burgers”. Make up your mind, or at least get your comments straight.

  3. Anna says:

    awesome article, I know for a fact she is one of the best caterers in this are, she makes a dynamite filet and salmon dishes & those morrocan meatballs are never enough (just eat them all) carrot cake & pecan bars are yummy too… Everything is wonderful!!!

  4. ann says:

    I didn’t know working for “rood” landscaping meant you had your “own”company

    • Jennifer says:

      I look forward to having you do my 40th!!!! I am always amazed that people get the chance to leave a comment and yet some have to have something negative to say.
      Mother’s must have not taught these folks, “If ya don’t have nothing nice to say, then don’t say anything at all” These people must be very unhappy people in life. And you know how the saying goes, they just must be JEALOUS!!!!

    • Holly Pratt says:

      That was a typo talk to the writer. Jon does in fact have a small business on the side.Rood is spelled with a Cap R!

  5. annb says:

    Does the pecan pie bar recipe REALLY require 1/8 cup of salt? I’d like to make it, but am having doubts about that amount.

  6. phynick says:

    moroccan meatballs with or without the dog hair? Been in her kitchen….FILTHY!!

  7. Jennifer says:

    Such ugly posts for ugly people. Once again, jelousy is an ugly beast and people have no class!! Steve + 20 year acquaintance > If you think she is not abiding the law, and drinking and driving- rather than lash out on a blog, why not do the correct thing and call the police? Your parents raised you with no common sense> “If you don’t have anything nice to say, than don’t say anything at ALL!”

  8. Ann says:

    Great article, too bad there are so many nasty disgruntled people in this world who can’t stand it when someone is successful!

  9. Holly Pratt says:

    I can see the color green coming out in my neighbors

  10. Lou says:

    OMG! No one deserves such comments!
    Holly and I have been neighbors for seventeen years and I know her to be a Super-Mom.
    As Jennifer quoted, “If ya don’t have nothing nice to say, then don’t say anything at all”.
    And Palm Beach Post, Shame On You for not reviewing these comments before allowing them to be posted!

  11. Steve says:

    I have read the Post for over forty years. I now know you will print anything to make money. Check your facts before you write an article. She does not talk about how I have to grab my young kids from the front yard when she gets in her van and drives down the the street. Come on PBP and Barbara (must be a friend of HOLLY) , how much did she pay you?

  12. Holly Pratt says:

    It only goes to show that some people have nothing better to do than be negative . Envy is a nasty monster. I have enjoyed my travels in 18 countries; the people I have met and the adventures I have encountered. With the book I’m writing if only the famous people I know buy it I’ll do well! C’est la vie to those who don’t experience and enjoy life.

  13. Anna says:

    Snarky reply aside, you’ve were very busy on 10/30/10, perhaps you should consider not responding to each and every comment on this article. Your hyper-sensitive blathering is not only tedious, but quite unbecoming.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] Palm Beach Entertainment: Events, movies, restaurants, nightlife & more | pbpulse.com » Dining [...]


Leave a Reply


We'd like your thoughts on this story. I appreciate your willingness to share them. At pbpulse.com, we want to avoid comments that are obscene, hateful, racist or otherwise inappropriate. If you post offensive comments, we will delete them as soon as we can. If you see such comments, please report them to us (video tutorial) by clicking on the date/time stamp of the comment and emailing that URL to this link.

Tim Burke, Publisher, The Palm Beach Post.



Cuisine categories

Twitter
Follow @pbpulsedining
RSS feed
Subscribe

Local Dining Events

Green market snapshots


Check out our picks and photos for some of the highlights of our local green markets, and even add your own.
Photos: Green Market snapshots | Add your own photos



Copyright 2012 The Palm Beach Post. All rights reserved. By using PalmBeachPost.com, you accept the terms of our visitor agreement. Please read it.
Contact PalmBeachPost.com | Privacy Policy
This website is ACAP-enabled