What we tested: American Beauty Beloved Collection Scents

Cost: $35 for set of three scents

Where: Kohl’s

Product claims: Experience a bouquet of delicate perfumes for every occasion in your life. American Beauty’s Beloved Garden Collection features all the fragrances in the Beloved collection, a perfect gift for the traveler in your life or someone who is looking to find a new signature scent. Set includes .45-ounce perfume spray bottles of: Beloved — an exquisite floral bouquet celebrating true romance and the exhilaration of being in love. Beloved Moments — a luscious bouquet of fresh flowers and dewy greens that celebrates happiness and nature. Beloved Red Rose — feel the passion of a rich, romantic love with a sensual fragrance featuring elegant Bulgarian rose with tuberose and gardenia.

Amy Royster, 33
Tried Beloved Moments

Cheap perfume is like cheap wine, it will give you a headache. After testing two of the scents in this three-scent set, and getting a headache two days in a row, I gave up on the third. Perfume is personal. Who knows why one person prefers musks to florals? So, I find it difficult to write perfume reviews, but I do think there is a certain level of quality that is fair to criticize. A perfume hangover is not a good sign.

Katie McBroom, 22
Tried Beloved Red Rose

My immediate thought at first whiff was that this fragrance should be sprayed on a love letter. Does anyone write those anymore? True to its name, the scent I tested smells exactly like a bouquet of fresh roses. It is incredibly delicate and feminine. If you don’t know someone well enough to guess their taste, this gift set is a safe bet. It comes with a variety of three very different fragrances at an affordable price.